· By Austin McKnight
Fixed Price vs. Cost-Plus vs. Turnkey: What You're Really Agreeing To
Fixed price, cost-plus, and turnkey get used like they mean the same thing. They don't. Here's what each one commits you to, what our loans require, and what to check before you sign.
- Construction
Your builder's contract decides what you'll pay, what you'll get, and who covers the bill when something costs more than expected. Three terms come up in almost every contract conversation: fixed price, cost-plus, and turnkey.
People often use them as if they mean the same thing. They don't. Two of them describe how you pay, and one describes what you get. Here's what each one really commits you to once construction starts, which ones we finance, and what to check before you sign.
The short answer
| Fixed price | Cost-plus | Turnkey | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it describes | How you pay | How you pay | What's included |
| Is the total set when you sign? | Yes, except changes you approve | No; a guaranteed maximum price sets only a ceiling | Not by itself; it depends on how you pay |
| Who absorbs cost overruns? | Mostly the builder | Mostly you | Depends on how you pay |
| What you're buying | The work in your plans and specs, for one total | The builder's actual costs, plus a fee | A finished home, ready to move in |
| The biggest thing to check | Exclusions, allowances, and escalation clauses | How the fee is figured and how costs are reported | Anything left out or priced separately |
| Do we finance it? | Yes, when it's also turnkey | No | Yes, when it's also fixed-price |
Fixed price is how you pay. Turnkey is what you get.
The easiest way to keep them straight: they answer two different questions.
- Fixed price answers "How will I pay?" You and the builder agree on one total for the work in your plans and specifications. If the builder's costs run higher, the builder absorbs the difference.
- Turnkey answers "What am I getting?" Everything from raw land to a finished, livable home is in the price: site work, utility connections, septic or sewer, well or water service, the driveway, permits, and final cleanup. When the builder hands you the keys, you can move in.
Because they answer different questions, a contract can be one, both, or neither:
- Fixed price, but not turnkey: a set price for the house, with the driveway, septic system, and utility hookups listed as "by owner." The house is priced. Finishing the home isn't.
- Turnkey, but not fixed price: a builder who will deliver everything down to the final cleanup, billed as costs come in. You get a complete home with no firm price.
- Both: one agreed total for a home that's ready to live in. That's the only kind of contract we finance.
See the side-by-side comparison in our glossary.
Why every loan we make requires both
Every construction loan we make, on every program, requires a contract that's both turnkey and fixed-price. That's our own program requirement, not a government rule, and here's the reason behind it.
A construction loan amount is set at closing, based on your contract price and the home's appraised value when it's finished. Once the loan closes, the amount can't go up. So if the price can move after closing, or if pieces of the job sit outside the contract, the difference has to come from somewhere. Usually that's your savings, in the middle of the build.
A fixed price keeps the total from drifting. Turnkey keeps the full cost of finishing the home inside that total. Together, they mean the number you close on is the number it takes to move in, apart from any changes you choose to make.
Many builders, including a lot of on-your-lot builders, already price this way. Your builder doesn't need construction-loan experience, either. We'll walk them through what we need.
Cost-plus, and why we don't finance it
In a cost-plus contract, you pay the builder's actual costs for labor and materials, plus a fee. The fee may be a percentage of those costs or a set dollar amount, which is sometimes called a fixed-fee contract.
Cost-plus has real strengths: you see where every dollar goes, and it can make sense when a design is still changing or a job is hard to price up front.
The catch is that no one knows the final price until the home is done. And when the fee is a percentage, the builder earns more as costs go up, which isn't the incentive you want.
Some cost-plus contracts add a guaranteed maximum price, or GMP: a ceiling the builder can't exceed without changes you approve. That's an improvement, but it's still a ceiling, not a price. You pay whatever the actual costs turn out to be up to that ceiling, and the fine print decides what counts toward it and who keeps any savings below it.
Because a construction loan amount is fixed at closing, we need a price that's fixed too. That's why we don't finance cost-plus contracts, with or without a GMP. If your builder usually works cost-plus, ask whether they'll price your home as a fixed-price, turnkey contract instead. Many will, once the plans and selections are complete.
What to check in a fixed-price contract
A fixed price is only as firm as what's written behind it. These are the four places a "fixed" price can still move.
Exclusions
Read what's excluded as carefully as what's included. Look for site work, utility hookups, septic or sewer, well or water, the driveway, permits and impact fees, appliances, landscaping, and window coverings. On our loans, everything it takes to make the home livable belongs in the price. If something essential shows up as an exclusion, ask the builder to add it, and talk to us before you sign.
Allowances
An allowance is a placeholder budget for something you haven't picked yet, such as cabinets, flooring, or lighting. If your choice costs more, you pay the difference. We discourage allowances, because each one is a piece of your price that isn't final yet.
We've seen a $20,000 cabinet allowance that didn't cover basic cabinets for the home it was written for. The best fix is to make your selections before you sign. If a few allowances remain, make sure each one is based on your plan and a real quote, not carried over from another job.
Change orders
A change order is a signed amendment that changes the work, the price, the schedule, or all three. Get every change in writing and signed before the work happens, even the small ones. Once plans are engineered and permitted, a "small" change can mean redrawing, re-engineering, and new approvals. And because your loan amount can't go up, added costs are paid out of pocket or, if approved, from your contingency.
Escalation clauses
An escalation clause lets the builder raise the price if certain costs, such as lumber, go up before or during construction. It can quietly turn a fixed price into a moving one. We discourage escalation clauses, though we understand why builders use them when material prices swing.
If your contract has one, find out what triggers it, how an increase is calculated, and whether there's a cap. Then build a contingency into your loan to cover it, because most people don't have extra cash on hand in the middle of a build. A contingency isn't required, but we strongly recommend one, and any unused funds are applied to your loan principal. How to include a contingency in your construction loan
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is this price fixed? What, besides changes I approve, could change it?
- Is the contract turnkey? Is anything excluded or listed as "by owner"?
- Are site work, utility hookups, septic or sewer, well or water, the driveway, and permits all in the price?
- Are there any allowances left? What is each one based on?
- How are change orders priced and approved? Is there a fee for each one?
- Is there an escalation clause? What triggers it, and is there a cap?
- Does your price include a contingency of your own? What does it cover?
- If you usually work cost-plus, will you price my home as fixed-price and turnkey?
Our guide to choosing a home builder covers the rest of the contract, including the fine print, and has a full list of questions to ask before you sign.
The bottom line
Fixed price tells you what you'll pay. Turnkey tells you what you'll get. You want both in writing, with as few allowances, exclusions, and escalation triggers as possible. That's the contract we require, and it's the one that protects you most once your loan closes.
Have a builder contract in hand? Send it to us before you sign, and we'll check it against our contract requirements. Talk with our team →