· By Austin McKnight

Make Your Selections Up Front: Allowances, Change Orders, and Keeping Your Price Final

Every selection you haven't made when you sign is a piece of your price that can still move. Here's how allowances and change orders work, and how to keep your price final.

  • Construction
Make Your Selections Up Front: allowances, change orders, and keeping your price final. By Austin McKnight, National Director of Construction.

When you sign a builder's contract, you're agreeing to a price for the home described in your plans and specifications. Anything you haven't decided yet isn't really priced. It's a placeholder, and placeholders can move.

That's why we tell every client the same thing: the more selections you make before you sign, the more final your price is. Here's how allowances and change orders work, why they matter even more on a construction loan, and how to keep both to a minimum.

Decided, allowed, or changed: the short version

Decided before you signLeft as an allowanceChanged after you sign
Is the cost known when you sign?YesNo, it's a placeholder budgetNo, it's a new cost
If it costs moreIt's already in your priceYou pay the differenceYou pay the added cost
Is it in the price your loan is based on?YesOnly up to the allowanceNo, and the loan amount can't go up
Effect on your scheduleNoneA late pick can hold up the workIt often adds time

Why your selections decide your price

A builder can only price what's been decided. Your plans and specifications describe the home: the drawings, plus the materials, products, and finishes that go into it. The more complete they are, the more accurate your price, and the fewer surprises you'll face later.

On a construction loan, that matters even more. Your loan amount is set at closing, based on your contract price and the home's appraised value when it's finished, and it can't go up after closing. So any cost that shows up later, whether it's an allowance that came up short or an upgrade you decide on halfway through, has to come from somewhere. Usually that's your savings, in the middle of the build.

What an allowance really is

An allowance is a dollar amount the contract sets aside for something you haven't picked yet: cabinets, countertops, flooring, tile, lighting, plumbing fixtures, or appliances. If what you choose costs more than the allowance, you pay the difference, usually through a change order. If it costs less, your contract may give you a credit.

Allowances let a builder price a home before every finish is chosen, so they're common. But each one is a piece of your price that isn't final yet, and that's why we discourage them.

How allowances go wrong

We've seen a $20,000 cabinet allowance that didn't cover basic cabinets for the home it was written for. That's the most common problem: an allowance that was never based on your home.

  • It's copied from another job. A number that worked for a smaller house, or a different price range, won't fit yours.
  • It's set too low. Whether anyone meant it or not, a low allowance makes the contract price look lower than the home will really cost.
  • It doesn't say what it covers. Does the cabinet allowance include installation? Does the lighting allowance cover the electrician's time, or just the fixtures? What about tax and delivery?
  • Overages cost more than you expect. Some builders add a markup or fee to the difference, on top of the extra cost itself.

If an allowance stays in your contract

Sometimes a few allowances make sense, especially for items you can't choose until later. If that's your situation:

  • Base each one on your plan and a real quote from the supplier you'll actually use.
  • Get in writing what each one includes: materials only or installed, and whether tax and delivery are in it.
  • Ask how overages are billed, whether there's a markup, and whether you get a credit if you come in under.
  • Agree on a deadline for each pick. Builders order materials ahead of the schedule, and a late choice can hold up the work.

How to make your selections up front

You don't need to pick every paint color before you sign. Focus on the choices with the biggest price swings: cabinets, countertops, flooring, tile, plumbing fixtures, lighting, appliances, windows and doors, and exterior finishes like brick, siding, and roofing.

  • Start early. Visit your builder's design center or the suppliers they use while the contract is still being priced, not after.
  • Get it in writing. Each choice belongs in your specifications or a signed selection sheet, with the brand, model, color, or style where it applies. "Granite countertops" isn't a selection. A named stone and edge profile is.
  • Price the whole package. Ask the builder to update the contract price once your selections are made, so the number you sign covers what you picked.
  • Review it all before work starts. Ask for a preconstruction meeting to go over the plans, specs, and selections with your builder. It's the cheapest place to catch a mistake.

On FHA, VA, and USDA loans, we also collect a Description of Materials from the builder, a standard form that lists the materials section by section. Selections made up front help make that form accurate too.

Change orders: keeping a final price final

Even with every selection made, plans change. A change order is a written, signed amendment to your contract that changes the work, the price, the schedule, or all three. It's how a change becomes part of the agreement instead of a disagreement at the end.

  • Get every change signed before the work happens, even the small ones. A quick "sure, we can do that" on site isn't a price, and many contracts say only what's in writing counts.
  • Make sure it shows the cost and the time. A good change order lists the new price, any fee, and how many days it adds to the schedule.
  • Know who can approve it. Changes should be signed by you and the builder, not settled with whoever is on site that day.
  • Change things on paper, not in the field. Moving a wall on the drawings costs little. Once plans are engineered and permitted, even a small change can mean redrawing, re-engineering, and new approvals from the building department or homeowners association. After framing, it can mean tearing out work that's already done.

Who pays for a change order

Because your loan amount can't go up after closing, a change that adds cost is paid out of pocket or, if approved, from your contingency. That's one of the best reasons to build a contingency into your loan. It isn't required, but we strongly recommend one, and any unused contingency is applied to your loan principal.

Learn more: How to include a contingency in your construction loan and how change orders fit into the draw process.

A note on escalation clauses

Selections and change orders are about choices you make. An escalation clause is about costs you don't control: it lets the builder raise the price if certain material costs go up. We discourage them, and if your contract has one, a contingency matters even more. We cover escalation clauses in our guide to fixed-price, cost-plus, and turnkey contracts.

Questions to ask before you sign

  1. Are all my selections made and written into the specs before I sign?
  2. Are there any allowances left? What is each one based on?
  3. Does each allowance include installation, tax, and delivery, or materials only?
  4. If my choice costs more than an allowance, how is the difference billed, and is there a markup? Do I get a credit if it costs less?
  5. When do you need each selection, and what happens if I'm late?
  6. How are change orders priced, approved, and paid? What fee or markup do you add?
  7. Will every change order show the price and the schedule impact before the work starts?
  8. Will we have a preconstruction meeting to review the plans, specs, and selections?

For the full list, see the questions to ask a builder before you sign in our guide to choosing a home builder, or download our printable builder questions checklist.

The bottom line

Allowances leave decisions for later. Change orders change decisions later. Either way, the cost lands after your loan amount is set. Make the big selections before you sign, get every change in writing before the work happens, and build in a contingency for what nobody can predict. That's how you keep the price you sign close to the price you pay.

Working through selections with your builder? Send us the contract before you sign, and we'll help you spot what's still open. Talk with our team →

Equal Housing Opportunity

Austin McKnight — NMLS #322977 | Branch — NMLS #1161933 | Primary Residential Mortgage, Inc. (PRMI) — NMLS #3094

PRMI NMLS: 3094. PRMI is an Equal Housing Lender. Some products and services may not be available in all states. Credit and collateral are subject to approval. Terms and conditions apply. This is not a commitment to lend. Programs, rates, terms and conditions are subject to change without notice. This office is licensed and examined by the Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner of the State of Texas. Department of Financial Institutions CL-3094.

NMLS Consumer Access

Member, Mortgage Bankers Association